What Is My Coney Island Home Worth?

Updated November 2026. In Coney Island, value depends on what the property is and how it is zoned: a single-family home, a duplex or small multifamily building, or a lot near Gulf Boulevard. Elevation, 2024 repairs and the 50% rule then separate original buildings from rebuilt ones. Request a free written valuation and we will show you where your home fits.

We are John and Nicole Kavaliauskas, licensed Florida Realtors with LoKation Real Estate. Coney Island is a neighborhood of the City of Treasure Island, so city flood and permit rules apply. Some listings call it Isle of Capri; county records file it under the Coney Island plat. For the neighborhood itself, see our Coney Island guide.

Every Coney Island sale in the last 12 months

Pinellas County Property Appraiser records list nine qualified sales in the Coney Island plats with sale dates from November 16, 2025 to November 16, 2026.

Street Type Built Heated sq ft Sold Price
Gulf Boulevard Motel 1956 3,188 May 2026 $2,255,000
First Street West Waterfront home 1977 1,464 Aug 2026 $2,000,000
Lagoon Lane Waterfront home, pool 2014 1,624 Jan 2026 $1,500,000
Lagoon Lane Waterfront home 2016 1,634 Nov 2025 $1,500,000
Lagoon Lane Waterfront home 1999 2,352 Mar 2026 $1,350,000
Gulf Boulevard Home, pool 2025 3,610 Sep 2026 $642,000*
Gulf Boulevard Duplex to fourplex 1934 1,797 Sep 2026 $490,000
125th Avenue Vacant lot n/a n/a Apr 2026 $279,000
125th Avenue Vacant lot n/a n/a May 2026 $279,000

*Recorded price. It is low for the size and age, so we would check the deed before using it as a comparable.

In the 12 months before (November 16, 2024 to November 15, 2025), the county recorded 11 sales in these plats, including eight single-family homes at a median of $387,500. Seven of those eight were interior homes.

Source: Pinellas County Property Appraiser comparable sales search, qualified sales, searched November 16, 2026. “Waterfront” is the Property Appraiser’s waterfront flag. Recent sales may not be recorded yet.

What the sales tell a Coney Island seller

Lagoon Lane homes held a tight range. Three waterfront homes on Lagoon Lane, built from 1999 to 2016, sold for $1,350,000 to $1,500,000. The two newest, at about 1,630 square feet each, both sold for $1,500,000, about $920 per heated square foot.

The top home sale was an older one. A 1977 waterfront home of 1,464 square feet on First Street West sold for $2,000,000.

Lots and income buildings trade lower. Two vacant lots on 125th Avenue sold for $279,000 each, and a 1934 duplex on Gulf Boulevard sold for $490,000.

Commercial parcels are their own market. A 1956 motel on Gulf Boulevard sold for $2,255,000. Zoning, not the house comparison, drives that kind of sale.

What drives home value in Coney Island

Property type and zoning. County parcel data shows single-family homes, about 47 duplexes and small multifamily buildings, and Gulf Boulevard motels. One listing places a Sunshine Lane parcel in the RFH-50 district, where Treasure Island permits tourist dwellings (listing). Zoning can change what an investor will pay, so we confirm it before pricing.

Water and walkability. Listings note a nearby public dock and a short walk to the beach and John’s Pass Village (listing).

Age and the 50% line. Older buildings that need work above the 50% line are often valued on the lot and the rebuild math.

Flood rules and disclosure in Coney Island

Buyers of an older building will ask about elevation, the 2024 storms, permits since then and any substantial damage letter. Treasure Island applies the FEMA 50% rule; see the city’s 50% rule page and post-hurricane FAQ. Our 50% rule guide for sellers and storm-damaged home guide cover the rule and Florida’s flood disclosure law.

How we value a Coney Island property

We price each property by hand from sold, pending, active and expired listings in Coney Island and nearby north-end streets that match your property type, zoning, elevation and condition. See what your free valuation includes.

Have ready: survey and elevation certificate, a zoning confirmation from the city, permits and final inspections for work since 2024, and leases and rent history for income property.

Next step

Request your free Coney Island home valuation, see Treasure Island home values, or call or text (727) 955-1222.

Other neighborhood value guides: Isle of Palms, Paradise Island, Capri Isle, Sunset Beach, Crystal Island, Gulf Shores, Bay Point Estates. Browse home values by town.

This page provides general information only and is not an appraisal or legal, tax, or insurance advice. Values depend on the specific property and current market conditions. Flood rules, substantial damage determinations, permitting and rental regulations change; verify with the city, Pinellas County, FEMA, your insurer or a licensed attorney. John and Nicole are licensed Florida Realtors with LoKation Real Estate.



Frequently asked questions


Pinellas County Property Appraiser records list four waterfront single-family sales from November 16, 2025 to November 16, 2026, from $1,350,000 to $2,000,000. Three were on Lagoon Lane.

Two vacant lots on 125th Avenue sold for $279,000 each in April and May 2026.

It can. One listing places a Sunshine Lane parcel in the RFH-50 district, where Treasure Island permits tourist dwellings, and zoning can change what an investor will pay. We confirm the zoning for your parcel before we price it.


English Deutsch