What Is My Bayway Isles Home Worth?

Updated November 2026. A Bayway Isles home is valued on the water, the lot and the house: the view and dock, the seawall, elevation and flood history from 2024, and what the City of St. Petersburg and the homeowners club will let the next owner do. Because buyers must be approved for club membership and short-term rentals are not allowed, your buyer pool is mostly owner-occupants and long-term holders. Request a free written valuation and we will show you where your home fits.

We are John and Nicole Kavaliauskas, licensed Florida Realtors with LoKation Real Estate. For the community itself, see our Bayway Isles guide.

Which rules apply

Bayway Isles is in the City of St. Petersburg. The St. Petersburg Police Department lists it in Patrol District 1, the city’s Neighborhood Relations directory includes the Bayway Isles Homeowners Club, and the club describes the community as within St. Petersburg. City flood, permit and rental rules apply, not the unincorporated Pinellas County rules that govern nearby Tierra Verde. The club’s deed restrictions apply on top of city rules.

Every Bayway Isles home sale in the last 12 months

Pinellas County Property Appraiser records list 12 qualified single-family sales in the Bayway Isles Unit 1 and Unit 2 Replat plats with sale dates from November 17, 2025 to November 17, 2026.

Street Type Built Heated sq ft Sold Price
52nd Street South Waterfront home, pool 2006 5,542 Jun 2026 $4,850,000
62nd Avenue South Waterfront home, pool 1966 4,827 Jun 2026 $3,550,000
59th Avenue South Waterfront home, pool 1973 4,322 Jan 2026 $3,100,000
58th Avenue South Waterfront home, pool 1965 3,627 Jan 2026 $2,550,000
51st Street South Waterfront home, pool 1986 3,469 Apr 2026 $2,500,000
61st Avenue South Waterfront home, pool 1966 3,282 May 2026 $2,000,000
60th Avenue South Waterfront home, pool 1995 2,906 Jan 2026 $1,600,000
58th Avenue South Waterfront home, pool 1981 3,177 Sep 2026 $1,325,000
Leeland Street South Interior home, pool 1989 2,790 Apr 2026 $1,305,000
51st Street South Interior home, pool 1982 2,494 May 2026 $1,300,000
Leeland Street South Interior home, pool 1965 2,278 Sep 2026 $1,200,000
Leeland Street South Interior home, pool 1979 2,688 Sep 2026 $948,000

The eight waterfront homes had a median of $2,525,000 and the four interior homes a median of $1,250,000. In the 12 months before (November 17, 2024 to November 16, 2025), the county recorded 13 single-family sales here at a median of $1,375,000: seven waterfront at a median of $2,225,000 and six interior at a median of $1,232,500.

Source: Pinellas County Property Appraiser comparable sales search, qualified sales, searched November 17, 2026. “Waterfront” is the Property Appraiser’s waterfront flag. Medians are Team BeachSide calculations. Recent sales may not be recorded yet.

What the sales tell a Bayway Isles seller

On the water, size counts more than age. Three of the four highest sales were original 1960s and 1970s waterfront homes of 3,600 to 4,800 square feet, at $2,550,000 to $3,550,000. The top sale was a 2006 waterfront home on 52nd Street South at $4,850,000, or $875 per heated square foot.

Waterfront alone does not set the price. A 1981 waterfront home on 58th Avenue South sold for $1,325,000, or $417 per heated square foot, and a 1995 waterfront home on 60th Avenue South for $1,600,000. Both landed close to the interior homes, so view, frontage and condition matter as much as the waterfront flag.

Interior homes hold a tight band. The four interior homes on Leeland Street South and 51st Street South sold for $948,000 to $1,305,000. New construction changes that math: the year before, a 2025 interior home on Leeland Street South sold for $3,662,000.

What drives home value in Bayway Isles

View, frontage and dock. Buyers compare open bay views with interior water views, frontage width, dock size and lift capacity. Serious boaters also check depth at the dock and along the route, and bridge clearance for their boat. Write down what boats your dock has handled. Our waterfront homes guide explains how buyers compare frontage.

Seawall, dock and lift. A seawall is one of the largest repair items a buyer can inherit. In Bayway Isles, docks, decks, tie poles and boat lifts also need club Building Committee review and Board approval, so buyers will want approval and permit records. See our seawall and dock inspection guide.

Gate and community. The club describes Bayway Isles as a 24 hour guarded, deed restricted island community of almost 200 families. Privacy and security are a large part of what buyers pay for here. The club’s information sheet for buyers and sellers requires buyers to be accepted for membership before closing, so build approval time into your contract timeline.

Age, elevation and insurance. The club says development began in 1964; the homes that sold this year were built from 1965 to 2006. Elevation drives flood insurance cost and future rebuild rules. Check your zone on the FEMA Flood Map Service Center, gather your elevation certificate, and see our flood zone and insurance guide.

Point Brittany condos

County records place the six Point Brittany condominiums on Brittany Drive South on Bayway Isles plats. They recorded 32 qualified sales in the last 12 months, from $110,000 to $500,000, with a median of $270,500. Each condominium has its own association and documents, so a Point Brittany seller should start with the building’s budget, reserves, inspections and rental rules. See our condo inspections, reserves and SIRS guide.

The 49% rule in St. Petersburg

Many people call it the FEMA 50% rule. The City of St. Petersburg uses 49%. Its substantial damage and substantial improvement page and permitting letter say that when repairs or improvements in a Special Flood Hazard Area equal or exceed 49% of the structure’s pre-damage market value, the whole structure must meet current zoning, building and floodplain standards. The city uses the Property Appraiser’s structure value and accepts an appraisal from a Florida state-licensed appraiser completed within the last 12 months. State law, section 163.31795, Florida Statutes, bars cumulative substantial improvement periods, so ask the city how it counts prior permits. Homes that need work above the 49% line are usually valued on the lot, the water and the rebuild math, and any rebuild here also needs club architectural approval.

Storm history and seller disclosure

The National Weather Service Helene impact summary reports that the St. Petersburg gauge set a record of 6.31 feet above mean higher high water on September 26, 2024. Florida’s flood disclosure law, section 689.302, Florida Statutes, applies to your sale; our storm-damaged home guide explains what it covers.

Rental rules

The club’s information sheet requires minimum 12-month leases, association approval of every lease and tenant, and bars short-term, commercial, event or seasonal rental of property, including docks. Accessory dwelling units are not permitted. The city’s transient accommodation handout also limits rentals of less than 30 days to three times in any consecutive 365-day period. Do not price a Bayway Isles home on vacation rental income.

Selling inside a deed-restricted community

The club’s information sheet requires an estoppel letter for every sale, with a fee. The club’s About page states that real estate signs are not permitted, so marketing relies on online exposure, agent networks and private showings. Order the estoppel early and tell buyers about the membership approval step up front. Ask the club about any pending projects, such as the bridge reconstruction referenced on its website, and how they are funded.

How we value a Bayway Isles home

We price each home by hand from sold, pending, active and expired listings in Bayway Isles first, then nearby bay-front homes that match your frontage, size, elevation and condition. See what your free valuation includes.

Have ready: a survey and frontage measurement, your elevation certificate, seawall inspection and dock permits with club approvals, permits and final inspections for work since 2024, insurance declarations pages, the estoppel and club fee schedule, and lease history if the home has been rented.

Next step

Request your free Bayway Isles home valuation. Nearby, see our Isla del Sol home value guide and Tierra Verde home value guide. Read how we market and sell a home on the Gulf Coast or our guide for Canadian sellers. Call or text (727) 955-1222 or send us a message.

This page provides general information only and is not legal, tax, or insurance advice. Flood rules, substantial damage determinations, permitting, deed restrictions, association rules and rental regulations change and apply differently to each property. Verify details with the City of St. Petersburg, Pinellas County, FEMA, the Bayway Isles Homeowners Club, your insurer, lender or a licensed attorney before making decisions. John and Nicole are licensed Florida Realtors with LoKation Real Estate.



Frequently asked questions


Twelve single-family homes sold from November 17, 2025 to November 17, 2026, from $948,000 to $4,850,000, according to Pinellas County Property Appraiser records. The eight waterfront homes had a median of $2,525,000.

Four interior homes on Leeland Street South and 51st Street South sold for $948,000 to $1,305,000 in the same period, with a median of $1,250,000.

County records show 32 qualified sales in the Point Brittany condominiums in the last 12 months, from $110,000 to $500,000, with a median of $270,500.

Yes. The club information sheet requires buyers to apply for and be accepted for membership before closing. An estoppel letter is also required for every sale.

No. The club requires minimum 12-month leases with approval and bars short-term, seasonal and event rentals, including docks.


English Deutsch